Reaching the Primary Inbox: An Email Deliverability Guide

Key Takeaways: How to Avoid the Promotions Tab

‍

If you’re in a rush, here is the TL;DR on landing in the Primary inbox:

• Humanise the Code: Use 'Plain-text' style templates with minimal HTML and fewer than 3 links.
• Authentication is Key: Ensure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC are correctly configured in your DNS.
• Engagement Signals: Encourage direct replies and remove inactive subscribers every 6 months to protect your sender reputation.
• Avoid 'Bypass' Scams: Don’t use 'proprietary code' hacks; they often lead to domain blacklisting.
• Leverage Soft Opt-ins: Use the UK soft opt-in rules (coming to charities in 2026 - click here for more) to grow your list, but maintain strict 'Primary-first' design to keep engagement high.

‍

Why Is Email Deliverability So Important?

‍

In a world where people increasingly say 'no' to third party cookies on websites, reaching them with digital ads is getting harder. It's also increasingly hard to maintain visibility with them using organic social media, where your reach is artificially suppressed (in a bid to get you to pay for more hard-to-run-successfully ads) and you only ever really 'rent' these audiences anyway.

‍

If you can, it's much better to try and obtain people's contact email addresses by offering value in exchange, and then you can keep in touch with them directly. First-party data gathering like this is now a cornerstone of good marketing which is why lead magnets and offers are suddenly so popular again.

‍

Obtaining email addresses is only part of the story though. Next, you need people to them to actually read your emails and take actions like clicking the links they contain.

‍

And this is where deliverability matters: if your emails all end up in a tab or folder your audiences rarely (if ever) bother to check, guess what? They don't get seen, so they can't be opened, and therefore don't get read.

‍

Why Bulk Emails Miss the Primary Inbox

‍

Even with a 100% opt-in list, Gmail and Outlook categorise emails based on 'markers.' Understanding these is the first step to improving your email marketing ROI.

‍

The 'Bulk Sender' Footprint

‍

When you use tools like Mailchimp, Brevo, or ActiveCampaign, your emails carry hidden technical headers. These identify the message as a broadcast. If your email also contains high HTML-to-text ratios (lots of images and columns), the algorithm automatically flags it as 'Promotional' rather than 'Personal.' If your recipient uses Gmail, then it's likely your email will end up in the Promotions tab where it may not be seen straight away (if at all). If they use Outlook, it will more than likely end up in 'Other' rather than 'Focused'.

‍

Even if you don't realise it, your Email Service Provider (ESP) includes technical metadata in the 'Header' of every email. While they don't necessarily send a note saying "There are 4,751 others," they do send signals that allow Gmail (and Outlook) to do the maths:

• The List-Unsubscribe Header Bulk tools include a specific piece of code that allows Gmail to show its own 'Unsubscribe' button at the top of the app. Automated one-to-one emails (like a download link) often use a different sending 'pool' or skip certain bulk headers that massive newsletters use.
• IP Warmth & Bursts When you send 16,500 emails at once, your ESP's IP address sends a massive 'burst' of data to Google’s servers. Their filters see 16,000 incoming connections from the same source at the same time. This is a massive 'Bulk Flag'.

‍

The Role of User Engagement

‍

AI-driven filters look at how recipients interact with your mail. If your 'open-to-ignore' ratio is low, your sender reputation drops. This is why list hygiene is more than just good practice - it’s a deliverability requirement.

‍

The Myth of 'Proprietary Code' Fixes

‍

Many software vendors claim to have 'proprietary code' that 'forces' emails into the Primary tab.

In fact, if you show any interest in email marketing whilst scrolling your Facebook feed, you're almost certain to be inundated with ads soon after all promoting email delivery software that guarantees it can circumvent the technology that impacts deliverability. Be cautious.

‍

These tools (often referred to as 'warm-up' services or specialised delivery plugins) claiming they have a 'secret code' or 'bypass' to trick Gmail or Outlook.

‍

The reality: There is no permanent hack. Google and Microsoft are multi-billion-dollar companies with world-class engineers; they cannot be tricked by a simple snippet of HTML.

• What these tools actually do: They usually just help you monitor your reputation or automate human-like engagement (like opening and replying to your own emails) to warm up your sender score. While these can have some minor benefits for new domains, they aren't a magic bullet.
• The Risk: Attempting to use sneaky code often backfires. If a filter detects you are trying to bypass its categorisation, it can flag your entire domain as suspicious. This is a far more serious problem to fix than simply landing in the Promotions tab because it can result in a permanent domain block.

‍

9 Ways You Can Improve Email Deliverability & Hit the Primary Inbox

‍

If you want to move from Promotions to Primary, you need to make your bulk email look and act more like a personal one.

1. Simplify your design Opt for Plain Text style templates. Avoid heavy banners, multiple columns, and complex CSS. A simple email with just text and one or two relevant images is far more likely to hit the Primary tab.
2. Reduce link count Aim for no more than 3 distinct links in the body of your email. This includes your main Call to Action, a link to your website, and your mandatory unsubscribe link. Excessive links, especially social media icons in the footer, are red flags.
3. Personalise beyond the name Use dynamic content features in your ESP (like ActiveCampaign’s "Conditional Content" or Mailchimp’s "Merge Tags") to send highly relevant paragraphs to different segments of your list. High relevance leads to high engagement, a strong signal for Primary status.
4. Set Up "Sender Authentication" (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) This is the technical "passport" for your email. If these aren't correctly configured in your domain's DNS settings, you won't just hit the Promotions tab - you'll likely hit the Spam folder. Consult your email service provider's guide for setting these up.‍
5. Encourage direct replies Include a genuine question at the end of your email, encouraging recipients to hit "reply." When a user replies to you, Gmail and Outlook see a "two-way conversation," which almost guarantees your future emails will go to their Primary tab.
6. Avoid 'salesy' triggers Words like "BUY NOW," "URGENT DONATION APPEAL," "FREE," or phrases implying immediate financial action in the subject line or the first 100 characters of the email body can be high-level triggers for the Promotions tab. Frame your calls to action around something else, and include them further down in your email.
7. Prune inactive subscribers ruthlessly If someone hasn't opened an email from you in 6 months, consider moving them to a 're-engagement' segment. If they still don't engage after a few attempts, remove them. Low open rates kill your overall Sender Reputation, dragging all your emails into the Other/Promotions tabs.
8. The "Move Me" campaign In your welcome email to new subscribers, explicitly ask them to "drag this email to your Primary tab" or "Add us to your contacts." This is a powerful, direct signal to the email algorithms that your content is valued.
9. Use a recognisable 'From' name Instead of sending from "Charity X Support" or "Info@SomeBusiness," send from "Sarah at Charity X" or "The Team at Business Y." A person's name or a friendly team reference is a 'Primary' marker; a generic department name is often interpreted as a promotional marker.

Final Thoughts On Improving Email Deliverbility

‍

We do a lot of email marketing for clients, and have directly observed that deliverability is always better when we send automated 'Welcome Series' emails one-at-a-time as people sign up to the lists we manage. Not only is deliverability enhanced, so is engagement. But when these people all start receiving weekly or monthly e-newsletters, deliverability and open rates drop. Here's what's going on and what to do about it.

‍

Delivery: The Small Batch Advantage

‍

As we explain above, bulk emails have telltale signatures that Gmail servers can spot. These are what cause your monthly e-newsletter to get routed to the Promotions tab.

‍

But automated welcome emails are sent one-at-a-time when someone signs up to your list. And even though you could get several people who subscribe simultaneously, there's a big difference between a few 10s and 20s doing so and receiving emails at roughly the same time, and hundreds or thousands of people all being emailed at the same time.

‍

Gmail treats these one-to-one automated emails more like transactional emails - like receipts or delivery of tickets etc - and so it prioritises them for the Primary inbox, judging them to be important.

‍

Engagement: The Priming Effect and 'Attention Decay'

‍

When a supporter interacts with your charity or a consumer engages with your business, their mental awareness of your brand is at its peak.

• Expectation They are literally looking at their inbox, primed and waiting for your name to appear. This leads to a near-instant open, which tells Gmail: "This sender is important to this user."
• The routine slump Once you move to a monthly newsletter or a fortnightly update, the urgency vanishes. If they miss one or two, the algorithm notices. Gmail thinks, "They used to care about this, but they don't anymore," and slowly demotes you from Primary to Promotions, and eventually perhaps even to Spam.

‍

What To Do

‍

Because you have a short window before you blend into the background noise, your strategy has to shift from Informing to Habit Forming.

‍

Front-load the value Don't save your best stories or offers for your monthly newsletter. Put your most high-impact content and special offers in front of people in the first 48-72 hours of their sign-up. In fact, don't even wait until the third email in your welcome flow, do it in first email you send - your audience members are at their most engaged and attentive having just made a purchase, obtained your lead magnet, or donated to your charity, and are also the most receptive to further 'asks'.

‍

Adopt a 'Micro-Conversion' strategy Use your automations to get the user to do more than just read. Ask them to reply to the email (this 'safelists' you for life in their inbox), click a preference link (this creates another high-value engagement signal), or save a contact card etc.

‍

Transitioning to the routine To prevent the drop-off when you move from 1-to-1 automations to bulk sends, segment by engagement - only send your bulk routine emails to people who have opened an email in the last 60-90 days. And, where possible, 'batch your bulk' - some tools, like Brevo that we use in our business, allow you to essentially 'drip' your bulk email send over several hours rather than blasting everyone in your list in one go, thus mimicking the behaviour of your 'Welcome' automations.

‍

‍

Found this blog interesting and insightful? Then show it some love and help more people benefit from its wisdom by sharing it on your social media for us and tagging us in! 

‍

Want some practical, hands-on help improving email deliverability? We can conduct a review of your current set-up, build you a tagging and segmentation structure, make sure your email authentication is in place and working as it should, create a three-part 'Welcome' series of automated emails for you, email templates, and more besides - just head to our contact page to start a conversation.

‍